The 100 Most Fuel-Efficient Cars in 2009

Have you ever wondered what the most fuel efficient cars manufactured in 2009 are? In this article, we'll list out the best 100 fuel efficient cars from 2009 with information on each of them!

How to Determine Fuel Efficiency

The list of the best fuel efficient cars on this page is based on one simple metric provided to us by the U.S. Department of Energy: the combined miles per gallon (MPG).

This metric is calculated by taking the total miles driven by the car and dividing it by the total gallons of fuel used.

Manufacturers provide this information to the Department of Energy, they provide it to us, and we provide it to you after sifting and organizing it.

The combined miles per gallon (MPG) is a measure of how much fuel the car uses per mile and is a good indicator of how efficient the car is. It's a combination of both city and highway driving, to give you a more overall accurate MPG.

With that out of the way, let's dive into the list. You can click the links in the table below to see more detailed information about each car.

Best 2009 Cars by Miles per Gallon

CarCombined MPGFuel Cost
Toyota Prius Automatic (variable gear ratios)46$1,350
Honda Civic Hybrid Automatic (variable gear ratios)42$1,500
smart fortwo convertible Automatic (AM5)36$2,050
smart fortwo coupe Automatic (AM5)36$2,050
Nissan Altima Hybrid Automatic (variable gear ratios)34$1,850
Toyota Camry Hybrid Automatic (variable gear ratios)34$1,850
Ford Escape Hybrid FWD Automatic (variable gear ratios)32$1,950
Mazda Tribute Hybrid 2WD Automatic (variable gear ratios)32$1,950
Mercury Mariner Hybrid FWD Automatic (variable gear ratios)32$1,950
MINI Clubman Manual 6-spd32$2,300
MINI Cooper Manual 6-spd32$2,300
MINI Cooper Convertible Manual 6-spd32$2,300
Toyota Yaris Manual 5-spd32$1,950
Volkswagen Jetta Automatic (S6)32$2,400
Volkswagen Jetta Manual 6-spd32$2,400
Volkswagen Jetta SportWagen Automatic (S6)32$2,400
Volkswagen Jetta SportWagen Manual 6-spd32$2,400
Honda Fit Automatic 5-spd31$2,000
Toyota Yaris Automatic 4-spd31$2,000
Chevrolet Aveo Manual 5-spd30$2,100
Chevrolet Aveo 5 Manual 5-spd30$2,100
Chevrolet Cobalt XFE Manual 5-spd30$2,100
Honda Fit Automatic (S5)30$2,100
Kia Rio Manual 5-spd30$2,100
Kia Rio Automatic 4-spd30$2,100
Nissan Versa FE Automatic (variable gear ratios)30$2,100
Pontiac G3 Wave Manual 5-spd30$2,100
Pontiac G3 Wave 5 Manual 5-spd30$2,100
Pontiac G5 XFE Manual 5-spd30$2,100
Toyota Corolla Automatic 4-spd30$2,100
Toyota Corolla Manual 5-spd30$2,100
Chevrolet Cobalt Manual 5-spd29$2,150
Chevrolet Malibu Hybrid Automatic 4-spd29$2,150
Honda Civic Manual 5-spd29$2,150
Honda Civic Automatic 5-spd29$2,150
Honda Fit Manual 5-spd29$2,150
Hyundai Accent Manual 5-spd29$2,150
Hyundai Accent Automatic 4-spd29$2,150
MINI Clubman Automatic (S6)29$2,550
MINI Clubman S Manual 6-spd29$2,550
MINI Cooper Automatic (S6)29$2,550
MINI Cooper Convertible Automatic (S6)29$2,550
MINI Cooper S Manual 6-spd29$2,550
MINI Cooper S Convertible Manual 6-spd29$2,550
MINI John Cooper Works Manual 6-spd29$2,550
MINI John Cooper Works Clubman Manual 6-spd29$2,550
MINI John Cooper Works Convertible Manual 6-spd29$2,550
Nissan Cube Automatic (variable gear ratios)29$2,150
Nissan Sentra FE Automatic (variable gear ratios)29$2,150
Nissan Versa Automatic (variable gear ratios)29$2,150
Nissan Versa Manual 5-spd29$2,150
Pontiac G5 Manual 5-spd29$2,150
Pontiac G5 GT Manual 5-spd29$2,150
Saturn Aura Hybrid Automatic 4-spd29$2,150
Scion xD Manual 5-spd29$2,150
Chevrolet Aveo Automatic 4-spd28$2,250
Chevrolet Aveo 5 Automatic 4-spd28$2,250
Ford Escape Hybrid 4WD Automatic (variable gear ratios)28$2,250
Ford Focus FWD Manual 5-spd28$2,250
Honda Civic CNG Automatic 5-spd28$1,250
Hyundai Elantra Automatic 4-spd28$2,250
Mazda Tribute Hybrid 4WD Automatic (variable gear ratios)28$2,250
Mercury Mariner Hybrid 4WD Automatic (variable gear ratios)28$2,250
Nissan Sentra Automatic (variable gear ratios)28$2,250
Nissan Versa Manual 6-spd28$2,250
Nissan Versa Automatic 4-spd28$2,250
Pontiac G3 Wave Automatic 4-spd28$2,250
Pontiac G3 Wave 5 Automatic 4-spd28$2,250
Pontiac Vibe Automatic 4-spd28$2,250
Pontiac Vibe Manual 5-spd28$2,250
Saturn Vue Hybrid Automatic 4-spd28$2,250
Saturn Vue Hybrid Automatic (variable gear ratios)28$2,250
Scion xD Automatic 4-spd28$2,250
Toyota Matrix Automatic 4-spd28$2,250
Toyota Matrix Manual 5-spd28$2,250
BMW 335d Automatic (S6)27$2,850
Chevrolet Cobalt Automatic 4-spd27$2,300
Dodge Caliber Manual 5-spd27$2,300
Ford Focus FWD Automatic 4-spd27$2,300
Hyundai Elantra Manual 5-spd27$2,300
Kia Spectra Automatic 4-spd27$2,300
Mazda 3 Manual 5-spd27$2,300
MINI Cooper S Convertible Automatic (S6)27$2,750
Nissan Sentra Manual 6-spd27$2,300
Nissan Versa Automatic 4-spd27$2,300
Pontiac G5 Automatic 4-spd27$2,300
Saturn Astra 2DR Hatchback Manual 5-spd27$2,300
Saturn Astra 2DR Hatchback Automatic 4-spd27$2,300
Saturn Astra 4DR Hatchback Automatic 4-spd27$2,300
Saturn Astra 4DR Hatchback Manual 5-spd27$2,300
Audi TT Coupe Automatic (S6)26$2,850
Chevrolet HHR FWD Manual 5-spd26$2,400
Chevrolet HHR Panel FWD Manual 5-spd26$2,400
Chevrolet Malibu Automatic (S6)26$2,400
Hyundai Elantra Touring Manual 5-spd26$2,400
Hyundai Elantra Touring Automatic 4-spd26$2,400
Kia Spectra Manual 5-spd26$2,400
Mercedes-Benz E320 Bluetec Automatic 7-spd26$2,950
MINI Clubman S Automatic (S6)26$2,850
MINI Cooper S Automatic (S6)26$2,850

Best 2009 Regular Fuel Cars by Miles per Gallon

The table below contains the best 2009 regular fuel cars by combined miles per gallon (MPG).

CarCombined MPGFuel Cost
smart fortwo convertible (Automatic (AM5))36$2,050
smart fortwo coupe (Automatic (AM5))36$2,050
MINI Clubman (Manual 6-spd)32$2,300
MINI Cooper (Manual 6-spd)32$2,300
MINI Cooper Convertible (Manual 6-spd)32$2,300
Toyota Yaris (Manual 5-spd)32$1,950
Volkswagen Jetta (Automatic (S6))32$2,400
Volkswagen Jetta (Manual 6-spd)32$2,400
Volkswagen Jetta SportWagen (Automatic (S6))32$2,400
Volkswagen Jetta SportWagen (Manual 6-spd)32$2,400
Honda Fit (Automatic 5-spd)31$2,000
Toyota Yaris (Automatic 4-spd)31$2,000
Chevrolet Aveo (Manual 5-spd)30$2,100
Chevrolet Aveo 5 (Manual 5-spd)30$2,100
Chevrolet Cobalt XFE (Manual 5-spd)30$2,100
Honda Fit (Automatic (S5))30$2,100
Kia Rio (Manual 5-spd)30$2,100
Kia Rio (Automatic 4-spd)30$2,100
Nissan Versa FE (Automatic (variable gear ratios))30$2,100
Pontiac G3 Wave (Manual 5-spd)30$2,100
Pontiac G3 Wave 5 (Manual 5-spd)30$2,100
Pontiac G5 XFE (Manual 5-spd)30$2,100
Toyota Corolla (Automatic 4-spd)30$2,100
Toyota Corolla (Manual 5-spd)30$2,100
Chevrolet Cobalt (Manual 5-spd)29$2,150
Honda Civic (Manual 5-spd)29$2,150
Honda Civic (Automatic 5-spd)29$2,150
Honda Fit (Manual 5-spd)29$2,150
Hyundai Accent (Manual 5-spd)29$2,150
Hyundai Accent (Automatic 4-spd)29$2,150
MINI Clubman (Automatic (S6))29$2,550
MINI Clubman S (Manual 6-spd)29$2,550
MINI Cooper (Automatic (S6))29$2,550
MINI Cooper Convertible (Automatic (S6))29$2,550
MINI Cooper S (Manual 6-spd)29$2,550
MINI Cooper S Convertible (Manual 6-spd)29$2,550
MINI John Cooper Works (Manual 6-spd)29$2,550
MINI John Cooper Works Clubman (Manual 6-spd)29$2,550
MINI John Cooper Works Convertible (Manual 6-spd)29$2,550
Nissan Cube (Automatic (variable gear ratios))29$2,150
Nissan Sentra FE (Automatic (variable gear ratios))29$2,150
Nissan Versa (Automatic (variable gear ratios))29$2,150
Nissan Versa (Manual 5-spd)29$2,150
Pontiac G5 (Manual 5-spd)29$2,150
Pontiac G5 GT (Manual 5-spd)29$2,150
Scion xD (Manual 5-spd)29$2,150
Chevrolet Aveo (Automatic 4-spd)28$2,250
Chevrolet Aveo 5 (Automatic 4-spd)28$2,250
Ford Focus FWD (Manual 5-spd)28$2,250
Honda Civic CNG (Automatic 5-spd)28$1,250
Hyundai Elantra (Automatic 4-spd)28$2,250
Nissan Sentra (Automatic (variable gear ratios))28$2,250
Nissan Versa (Manual 6-spd)28$2,250
Nissan Versa (Automatic 4-spd)28$2,250
Pontiac G3 Wave (Automatic 4-spd)28$2,250
Pontiac G3 Wave 5 (Automatic 4-spd)28$2,250
Pontiac Vibe (Automatic 4-spd)28$2,250
Pontiac Vibe (Manual 5-spd)28$2,250
Saturn Vue Hybrid (Automatic (variable gear ratios))28$2,250
Scion xD (Automatic 4-spd)28$2,250
Toyota Matrix (Automatic 4-spd)28$2,250
Toyota Matrix (Manual 5-spd)28$2,250
BMW 335d (Automatic (S6))27$2,850
Chevrolet Cobalt (Automatic 4-spd)27$2,300
Dodge Caliber (Manual 5-spd)27$2,300
Ford Focus FWD (Automatic 4-spd)27$2,300
Hyundai Elantra (Manual 5-spd)27$2,300
Kia Spectra (Automatic 4-spd)27$2,300
Mazda 3 (Manual 5-spd)27$2,300
MINI Cooper S Convertible (Automatic (S6))27$2,750
Nissan Sentra (Manual 6-spd)27$2,300
Nissan Versa (Automatic 4-spd)27$2,300
Pontiac G5 (Automatic 4-spd)27$2,300
Saturn Astra 2DR Hatchback (Manual 5-spd)27$2,300
Saturn Astra 2DR Hatchback (Automatic 4-spd)27$2,300
Saturn Astra 4DR Hatchback (Automatic 4-spd)27$2,300
Saturn Astra 4DR Hatchback (Manual 5-spd)27$2,300
Audi TT Coupe (Automatic (S6))26$2,850
Chevrolet HHR FWD (Manual 5-spd)26$2,400
Chevrolet HHR Panel FWD (Manual 5-spd)26$2,400
Chevrolet Malibu (Automatic (S6))26$2,400
Hyundai Elantra Touring (Manual 5-spd)26$2,400
Hyundai Elantra Touring (Automatic 4-spd)26$2,400
Kia Spectra (Manual 5-spd)26$2,400
Mercedes-Benz E320 Bluetec (Automatic 7-spd)26$2,950
MINI Clubman S (Automatic (S6))26$2,850
MINI Cooper S (Automatic (S6))26$2,850
Nissan Altima (Manual 6-spd)26$2,400
Nissan Altima (Automatic (variable gear ratios))26$2,400
Nissan Altima Coupe (Manual 6-spd)26$2,400
Nissan Altima Coupe (Automatic (variable gear ratios))26$2,400
Nissan Cube (Manual 6-spd)26$2,400
Nissan Sentra (Automatic (variable gear ratios))26$2,400
Pontiac G5 GT (Automatic 4-spd)26$2,400
Pontiac G6 (Automatic (S6))26$2,400
Saturn Aura (Automatic (S6))26$2,400
Suzuki SX4 Sedan (Automatic 4-spd)26$2,400
Acura TSX (Automatic (S5))25$2,950
Audi A4 (Automatic (variable gear ratios))25$2,950
Audi A4 Cabriolet (Automatic (variable gear ratios))25$2,950

Conclusion

The most fuel efficient car of 2009 is the Toyota Prius. It has a combined MPG of 46 and costs $1,350 per year to drive it.

The most fuel efficient non-electric car of 2009 is the smart fortwo convertible. It has a combined MPG of 36 and costs $2,050 per year to drive it.

Most Fuel Efficient Cars By Year

Link To or Reference This Page

If you use this page in your research, please reference MPG Buddy as the source.

  • "The 100 Most Fuel-Efficient Cars in 2009." MPG Buddy. Accessed on January 3, 2026. https://mpgbuddy.com/most-fuel-efficient-cars-in-2009.

  • "The 100 Most Fuel-Efficient Cars in 2009." MPG Buddy, https://mpgbuddy.com/most-fuel-efficient-cars-in-2009. Accessed January 3, 2026.

  • The 100 Most Fuel-Efficient Cars in 2009. MPG Buddy. Retrieved from https://mpgbuddy.com/most-fuel-efficient-cars-in-2009.